小学高年级学生的学习判断绝对准确性及预见偏差

心理发展与教育 ›› 2012, Vol. 28 ›› Issue (1): 54-60.

小学高年级学生的学习判断绝对准确性及预见偏差

贾宁¹, 代景华²

1. 河北师范大学教育学院, 石家庄050024;
2. 河北医科大学西山校区, 石家庄050228

出版日期:2012-01-15 发布日期:2012-01-15
通讯作者: 贾宁,E-mail:jnajh@126.com E-mail:jnajh@126.com
基金资助:
河北省教育厅人文社科项目“学习进程中的自我监控”(S2010604)

Judgments of Learning of The Higher Graders in Elementary School: Absolute Accuracy and the Foresight Bias

JIA Ning¹, DAI Jing-hua²

1. School of Education, Hebei Normal University, Shijiazhuang 050024;
2. Hebei Medical University at Xishan, Shijiazhuang 050228

Online:2012-01-15 Published:2012-01-15

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 本研究以小学高年级学生为被试,选取高熟悉度的具体名词组成的联结词对为实验材料,考察不同判断模式下学习判断的准确性及预见偏差。研究发现:(1)小学高年级学生的学习判断绝对准确性存在年级差异。总体来看,小学六年级学生在即时判断和延迟判断模式下都具有较好的绝对准确性,而四年级和五年级学生在即时判断时出现显著的高估,而在延迟判断模式下具有较好的绝对准确性。具体分析正向词对和反向词对的准确性发现,在即时判断模式下,五、六年级学生的正向联结词对有较好的准确性,而四年级的正向联结词对出现高估;三个年级的学生的反向词对都出现高估。在延迟判断模式下,三个年级学生在正向词对和反向词对上都有较好的准确性。(2)小学五年级学生的学习判断开始出现预见偏差。(3)延迟判断能够提高小学高年级学生的学习判断准确性,减小甚至消除预见偏差。

关键词: 小学高年级学生, 学习判断, 绝对准确性, 预见偏差

Abstract: In the present study,4～6^th graders of primary school participated in the experiment,and the concrete noun pairs were selected as experimental materials.Experiment 1 explored the foresight bias of immediate JOLs.In experiment 1,subjects were instructed that they would have to study 30 paired associates and would have to indicate their JOLs about each pair as soon as it disappeared from the screen.They were told that in the test phase,they would see each stimulus word in turn and would be asked to recall the corresponding response word.Experiment 2 explored the foresight bias of delayed JOLs.The conclusions are that(1)there are age differences in the absolute accuracy of immediate JOLs.Specially,age differences are different in the forward and backward associations.(2) There are age differences in the foresight bias.When students making immediate JOL,there were foresight biases in the JOLs of fifth and sixth graders,but not in the JOLs of fourth-graders.(3)Foresight bias induces students to overestimate their memory.Delayed JOL can reduce the foresight bias.

Key words: the higher graders in elementary School, judgment of learning, absolute accuracy, foresight bias

中图分类号:

G442

贾宁, 代景华. 小学高年级学生的学习判断绝对准确性及预见偏差[J]. 心理发展与教育, 2012, 28(1): 54-60.

JIA Ning, DAI Jing-hua. Judgments of Learning of The Higher Graders in Elementary School: Absolute Accuracy and the Foresight Bias[J]. Psychological Development and Education, 2012, 28(1): 54-60.

参考文献

[1] Castel,A.D.,McCabe,D.P.,&Roediger,H.L.(2007).Illusions of competence and overestimation of associative memory for identical items-Evidence from judgments of learning.Psychonomic Bulletin&Review,14(1),107-111.
[2] Coyle,T.R.,&Bjorklund,D.F.(1996).The development of strategic memory:A modified microgenetic assessment of utilization deficiencies.Cognitive Development,11,295-314.
[3] Koriat,A.,&Ma'ayan,H.(2005).The effects of encoding fluency and retrieval fluency on judgments of learning.Journal of Memory and Language,52,478-492.
[4] Koriat,A.(1997).Monitoring one's own knowledge during study:a cue-utilization approach to judgments of learning.Journal of Experimental Psychology:General,126,349-370.
[5] Koriat,A.,&Bjork,R.A.(2005).Illusions of competence in monitoring one's knowledge during study.Journal of Experimental Psychology:Learning,Memory,and Cognition,31(2),187-194.
[6] Koriat,A.,&Bjork,R.A.(2006a).Mending metacognitive illusions:A comparison of mnemonic-based and theory-based procedures.Journal of Experimental Psychology:Learning,Memory,and Cognition,32(5),1133-1145.
[7] Koriat,A.,&Bjork,R.A.(2006b)Illusions of competence during study can be remedied by manipulations that enhance learners' sensitivity to retrieval conditions at test.Memory and Cognition,34 (5),959-972.
[8] Meeter,M.,&Nelson,T.O.(2003).Multiple study trials and judgments of learning.Acta Psychologica,113,123-132.
[9] Nelson,T.O.,&Dunlosky,J.(1991).When people's judgments of learning(JOLs)are extremely accurate at predicting subsequent recall:The "delayed-JOL effect" .Psychological Science,2(4),267-270.
[10] Schneider,W.,Vise,M.,Lockl,K.,&Nelson,T.O.(2000).Developmental trends in children's memory monitoring evidence from a judgment-of-learning task.Cognitive Development,15,115-134.
[11] Tiede,H.L.,&Leboe,J.P.(2009).Illusions of Competence for Phonetically,Orthographically,and Semantically Similar Word Pairs.Canadian Journal of Experimental Psychology,63(4),294-302.
[12] Van overschelde,J.P.,&Nelson,T.O.(2006).Delayed judgments of learning cause both a decrease in absolute accuracy(calibration)and an increase in relative accuracy(resolution).Memory and Cognition, 34(7),1527-1538.
[13] 北京语言学院语言教学研究所编.(1986).现代汉语频率词典.北京:北京语言学院出版社.
[14] 韩凯,李波,刘海娟.(2003).自由回忆中元记忆监测的作用及其影响因素.心理学报,35(2),157-162.
[15] 刘希平,唐卫海.(2002).回忆准备就绪程度的判断发展.心理学报,34(1),56-60.
[16] 俞国良,侯瑞鹤.(2009).学习不良儿童的元认知偏差:内部线索的影响.应用心理学,15(2),120-130.
[17] 俞国良,张雅明.(2006).学习不良儿童元记忆监测特点的研究.心理发展与教育,(3),1-5.
[18] 周楚,刘晓明,路海东.(2003).学习困难儿童元记忆能力的实验研究.心理与行为研究,1(3),190-193.

多维度评价

Viewed

Full text

Abstract

Cited

Shared

Discussed