目标设置对写作困难儿童议论文说服力的促进效应研究

心理发展与教育 ›› 2006, Vol. 22 ›› Issue (1): 69-73.

目标设置对写作困难儿童议论文说服力的促进效应研究

吴洪珺, 刘翔平, 杜英

北京师范大学心理学院, 北京, 100875

出版日期:2006-01-15 发布日期:2006-01-15
通讯作者: 刘翔平,男,北京师范大学心理学院教授;E-mail:lxp599@163.com E-mail:lxp599@163.com
基金资助:
教育部十五教育规划博士点基金项目“学习障碍的认知机制、诊断与干预研究”课题(01JBXL004);全国教育规划十五教育部重点课题阅读障碍的亚类型研究(DBB030239)的资助

The Facilitating Effects of Goal Setting on the Persuasiveness of Writing Difficulties Students’ Persuasive Essays

WU Hong-jun, LIU Xiang-ping, DU Ying

School of Psychology, Beijing Normal University, Beijing 100875

Online:2006-01-15 Published:2006-01-15

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 将写作困难儿童随机分入三个不同的目标设置组,总目标设置条件要求儿童根据话题写议论文,目标为文章应能说服读者赞同他们的观点;分目标设置条件对儿童有同样的要求,但给儿童提供了以议论文的基本构成为基础的分目标;辩论加分目标设置除了与分目标设置组相同的条件外,还要求儿童在写作前进行辩论。研究结果表明,分目标设置组儿童的议论文比总目标设置组和辩论加分目标设置组儿童的议论文更具说服力度。在文章构成成分上,分目标设置组和辩论加分目标设置组要好于总目标设置组。这三种目标设置中,分目标对写作困难儿童的议论文说服力有很大的促进作用。

关键词: 目标设置, 分目标设置, 写作困难

Abstract: Students with writing dif iculties wrote persuasive essays in 3 different goal conditions.Students in the general goal condition were asked to write an essay according to a topic,and the general goal is that the audience should be agree with their positions.Students in the subgoal condition were given the same general goal plus explicit subgoals based on the elements of argumentative discourse.Students in the oral argument condition were showed the same general goal and subgoals,besides,they also had an oral argument with their partners before writing.The result was that students in the subgoal condition produced more persuasive essays than the general goal condition and the oral argument plus subgoal condition.Students in the subgoal condition and the oral argument plus subgoal condition wrote more integrated essays than the general goal condition.In all goal conditions,subgoal improved the essays' persuasiveness of students with writing difficulties the most.

Key words: goal-setting, subgoal setting, writing difficulties

中图分类号:

G442

吴洪珺, 刘翔平, 杜英. 目标设置对写作困难儿童议论文说服力的促进效应研究[J]. 心理发展与教育, 2006, 22(1): 69-73.

WU Hong-jun, LIU Xiang-ping, DU Ying. The Facilitating Effects of Goal Setting on the Persuasiveness of Writing Difficulties Students’ Persuasive Essays[J]. Psychological Development and Education, 2006, 22(1): 69-73.

参考文献

[1] Noel G,Nancy M.School Is Fun at Recess:Informal Analyses of Written Language for Students with Learning Disabilities.Journal of Learning Disabilities.Volume 35,Number 1,January/Febuary,2002,7-22.
[2] 转引自 Ralph P F,Charles A M,Nancy S D.The Effects of an Elaborated Goal on the Persuasive Writing of Students With Learning Disabilities and Their Normally Achieving Peers.Journal of Educational Psychology,2000,Vol.92,No.4,694-702.
[3] Ralph P F,Charles A M,Nancy S D.The Effects of an Elaborated Goal on the Persuasive Writing of Students With Learning Disabilities and Their Normally Achieving Peers.Journal of Educational Psychology,2000,Vol.92,No.4,694-702.
[4] 张肇丰,当代西方写作过程模式的研究与发展.心理科学,2003,26,2,346-347
[5] Page-Voth V,Graham S.Effects of Goal Setting and Strategy Use on the Writing Performance and Self-Efficacy of Studenta With Writing and Learning Problems.Journal of Educational Psychology,1999,vol.91,No.2,230-240.
[6] Virginia W B,Katherine V,Robert D A,Kristin B C.Gerald,Gerald Curtin,Jill Minich Hawkins and Steve Graham.Teaching Spelling and Comprehension Alone and Together:Implications for the Simple View of Writing.Journal of Educational psychology.2002,Vol.94,No.2,291-304.
[7] Nixon J G,Topping K J.Emergent Writing:the impact of structured peer interaction.Educational Psychology,2001,21,41-58.
[8] 周泓,张庆林.近二十年国内写作心理研究述评.心理科学,2003,26(4),690-693.
[9] 戴建林,莫雷.西方关于写作过程的自我调控研究的进展.心理发展与教育,1999,3,54-57.

多维度评价

Viewed

Full text

Abstract

Cited

Shared

Discussed